CineBuff's MovieNerd Review for The Mentalist

The Mentalist

TV

2008

The Mentalist is truly a masterpiece of the crime-procedural genre. Unlike other series that rely on gimmicky psychic tropes, unnecessary clues, or forced comedy, this show maintains a level of decency and focus that kept me hooked from the first episode to the last. What sets this show apart is Patrick Jane himself. Watching him "read" people is endlessly fascinating—it's not magic, but rather an incredible display of observation and human psychology. The series does a fantastic job of balancing the heavy, personal stakes of Jane's quest for justice with the daily satisfaction of solving complex cases. Even when the show faced major shifts in its structure or cast, the writing remained sharp, eventually leading to a deeply satisfying and happy ending that rewarded the audience for sticking with the journey. If you appreciate a show that prioritizes intelligent characters and consistent storytelling over cheap thrills, The Mentalist is essential viewing.

07/18/2026

8/10

Review Score

Visit the TV Page

There is much more information about this TV Show on its page. View actors, crew, full ratings, and more!

Go to TV Show Page

Filmmaking

90

Overall

92

Screenplay

95

Acting

85

Cinematography

85

Production

88

Directing

90

Concept

88

Story

90

Dialogue

95

Characters

85

Pacing

80

Musical Score

Attributes

95

Entertaining

88

Uniqueness

95

How Much I Like It

85

Twists

80

Artistry

85

Fun

20

Cliche

15

Cheesy

90

Broad Appeal

90

Cerebral

85

Emotional

85

Discussion Worthy

Genres

60

Action

50

Comedy

90

Drama

85

Suspense

95

Mystery

90

Thriller

10

Horror

30

Adventure

40

Romance

0

Science Fiction

0

Fantasy

0

Animation

Maturity

40

Family Friendly

80

Positive Message

85

Thematically Mature

75

Intense

10

Sexuality

5

Nudity

60

Violence

20

Gore

10

Crude

30

Profanity

30

Scary

10

Substance Use

Share This Review

Click box below to copy link

Loading Preview...